American Idol: The Women
I love American Idol. I actually love Kelly Clarkson - Breakaway is a great album, and unlike many, I have forgiven her for not thanking American Idol when she won the grammys because I just adore the live version of Beautiful Disaster. I can boycott Dominos for providing funding to anti-abortion causes back in the 80s; I can't sit in cracker barrell deck chairs because of their discriminatory practices in the 80s; I even boycotted CBS in protest for cancelling Cagney & Lacey again in the 80s; but don't make me boycott my Kelly! I am also a Claymate. I admit it. I love Barry Mannilow too! So, what's your point? Anyway, tonight is the women's competition and here are my thoughts:
Ryan Seacrest makes me absolutely crazy. Metrosexual. Whatever. I am so done with his odd reversable blue velvet jacket.
Lordy Lordy Paula's had a Forty! And a botox treatment for good measure. Can she not feel that wisp of hair that is stuck in her mouth? Watching Paula is like watching Dora the Explorer. Have you seen this? Basically Dora is Bilingual and educational - donde esta dora - anyway, she asks questions of the audience and there is this silence as she waits for the tv audience response. For instance Dora will say "have you seen the sheep?" Then there is silence and dora and her sidekick money are looking all around waiting for the answer. Finally after what seems to be hours, Dora says something like "oh thank you there are the sheep. gracias." As an adult this is the most bizare thing. Well, Paula is just like that but in live version - she speaks a couple garbled words and then she stops to collect her thoughts (and you can feel Ryan, Randy, Simon, the camera man, and the music director just looking around like do we interject or cut to Simon, what do we do) and then miraculously Paula recovers and adds the hand air pump or moves her head to the side and comes up with some impressive retort like: Its taking risks but taking risks in the right direction; You're wowing us; and I want to squish you.
And here is the competition:
1. Katharine blunders through Stevie Wonder. Is there some hidden sexual tension between her and her roomie or is it my perspective. Gunny Gunny outfit. And by Gunny Gunny I mean - no one should wear a shirt with the built in visible bra with the high waist. It is not flattering, sexy or anything but Gunny Guynny. And if you can't work a mike please don't try the hystrionics of grabbing it out of the stand. Her mom knows she sucks tonight.
2. Kinnik - GOODNESS she should not be in a cowboy outfit because she looks like a really bad drag queen. Not sure what song she is trying to sing. Not sure what to say other than...fast forward.
3. Lisa - she's cute and I like her personality but what a horrendous song choice. She is screaming into the mic. Her parents are cute and singing the song but maybe they should be up there for her. She can hold the notes and has perfect arches in those eyebrows so, hello Lisa. Overall horrible.
4. Melissa - aka: Oh my god I was wearing FLIP FLOPS on the red carpet girl. Chunkalina women should not really wear belly shirts. I have belly chunk and sometimes wear outfits that are the slightest bit short and when I run my hands through my curly locks I flash a bit of skin and I know its not attractive. But this woman thinks she rocks. She did ok with the song. I thought it was a reach song because she really just screamed into the mic and tried way too hard but comparatively it was the best so far. She just ruined it by explaining herself. Then the pan to the family - the beehive went out years ago sister.
5. Heather - she should have been kicked last week and this week she chose Hero by Maraih Carey which she claims was never sung which of course I challenge. Didn't that hairdresser from Connecticut sing that song? And if anyone put a boa on my neck I would have peed. There is CLEARLY a reason songs aren't sun on AI. Namely this one by Heather. The makeup artist must be Tammy Faye Baker because wow it is bad. These kids look like prostitutes. Honestly, how hard is it to pick a song. and when did the tube top come back?
6. Brenna - ok last dance great song choice. Great outfit for the song with the disco ball earings and the geri curl. I like her attitude. Hitting the first few notes is important. And maybe clear deodarant is in order. Is everyone screaming tonight or am I just tired. She is not giving it her all and suprisingly enough can't really move all that well while singing. She tried to pull it out in the end in that Velma from Good Times kind of way but failed. This egomaniac needs to be kicked.
7. Paris. Now I love her and she is absolutely talented. But she comes from a family who is in show business and she would be hooked up a million times from Sunday so I don't really think she needs to be on this show. She has an unfair advantage - really its like me entering a lounge lizard karaoke competition - just unfair. Now, I would have the good common sense to not choose Wind Beneath my Wings and wear a bizare choker. What has happened to her? Has she become too pop? Why is she abandoning her natural talent? Give us some more Billie Holiday. We know she has range - not everyone can pull off Billie. How she can pull Billie but NOT Bette is sort of comical but alas what do I know. She is amazing and so young but she will and would have gotten a contract regardless of AI.
8. Ayla. Our future BC ball player who now owns so many different tank tops. I have had it and hate everyone tonight. What song is this? Horrible. Horrible. And the hair. Is she even on key. Gads. Fast forward. Horrendous. And they loved her. wow!
9. Kelly. NC girl. Another who should have gone last week. Bonnie Raitt didn't whisper this song and starting so quietly doesn't ..hold that thought...no she didn't get a weave? IS that a weave? Are those pedal pushers? Is she on key? What was that weird move and eye and hair thing? Does she know she is not making porn? She rocked with the bedazzler on her shirt and espadrills. And her voice was actually the best and she did have fun. I certainly have not fallen in love with her and she is absolutely NOT Kelly!
10. Mendisa. LOL on Dog Jaw. The mumus rock! But so Whats her name Price. Everyone is OFF tonight. She has a freaking fantastic voice and is one of my favorites despite the porr song choice.
I hope the men are better tomorrow night.